Medical Marijuana Pros and Cons: Expert Opinions

Important Caution. Please Read This!

Use the information on this site AT YOUR OWN RISK, and read the disclaimer.








Subscribe for Free!

Never miss a post or update.

BONUS: Right now, you'll also receive "The Survival Doctor's Ultimate Emergency Medical Supplies" report—FREE!

We respect your email privacy.

 Subscribe in a reader

Find The Survival Doctor on FacebookFollow The Survival Doctor on TwitterFollow Me on PinterestSubscribe to me on YouTube

This survival-medicine website provides general information, not individual advice. Most scenarios assume the victim cannot get expert medical help. Please see the disclaimer.

Medical Marijuana Pros and Cons: Expert Opinions

Two experts debate the pros and cons of medical marijuana, offering opinions on whether it should be legalized.

[Editor's note: This article was originally hosted on MyFamilyDoctorMag.com, our sister site.
It's now featured here as part of our new general-health section.]

Medical Marijuana Pros and Cons: Expert Opinions | The Survival Doctor

 

Is marijuana a harmful drug or a beneficial medicine? Put all the arguments together and you might answer, “a little of both.” But then the questions just start growing:

  • Does medical marijuana’s good outweigh its bad?
  • Legal medicines also have side effects; are marijuana’s any worse?
  • Are other medicines more effective than marijuana?
  • Does marijuana even do the good things proponents claim it does?

To help answer those questions, we asked two experts to share their opinions on medical marijuana. But first, a little background:

Some Cons of Medical Marijuana

Marijuana can be addictive and have short-term side effects like memory loss and trouble thinking. It may have harmful long-term effects, like lung cancer, a weakened immune system, and increased heart-attack risk in the hour after smoking it.

Some Pros of Medical Marijuana
Rules of Engagement

We invited each participant to write an argument, then read the opponent’s argument and, if desired, write a rebuttal. Neither was allowed to read the other’s initial argument before writing his own, and neither could read the other’s response before rebutting.

Marijuana also may have good health effects, like treating glaucoma, nausea, appetite loss and seizures. Proponents say it’s helpful for people experiencing side effects from AIDS and cancer medications and may help treat multiple sclerosis and epilepsy.

Official Positions

Medical marijuana is illegal at the federal level. But it’s legal in certain states. Those states won’t come after providers, but the federal government can. Confused? Don’t blame ya.

In its policy statement, the American Medical Association recommends that for now, marijuana remain classified as a Schedule I Controlled Substance. The government deems drugs in this category to have a high abuse potential, no accepted medical use and a lack of acceptable safety.

Then again, the AMA sees enough promise to recommend more studies on the drug and urges the National Institutes of Health “to implement administrative procedures to facilitate grant applications and the conduct of well-designed clinical research into the medical utility of marijuana.”

We asked two mental-health providers: Should marijuana be legal for certain medical purposes? Here’s what they had to say. You can also get in on the debate here.


Pro Argument: Medical Marijuana Should Be Legal.

Marijuana is a lousy drug but can be a great medication. The same applies to most medications. Drugs can be used for medicinal purposes and/or abused in order to alter mood and run away from life.

There is no question that marijuana should be considered a dangerous drug. It is carcinogenic, mood altering, motivation destroying and life wrecking. In the alternative, the same may be said for such dangerous medications as Valium, opiates, diet pills and even Tylenol. When any medication is misused it becomes a clear and present danger.

Pro

mitch-wallickMitch Wallick, Ph.D., C.A.P., F.A.B.F.C.E., C.M.H.P., is executive director of C.A.R.E. Addiction Recovery, a holistic drug rehabilitation facility in North Palm Beach, Fla. He holds Ph.D.s in both counseling and addictions.

Chemicals are neither good nor bad. We should not make moral judgments on substances.Instead, we need to focus our debate on the benefit-risk ratio of use versus nonuse.

Most of us would certainly argue that cocaine is a “bad drug.” It should be outlawed! What many laypeople fail to realize is that cocaine has a legitimate medical use in reconstructive surgery. It is a good topical anesthetic and a vasoconstrictor, which helps to minimize bleeding. This is a good use of cocaine.

On the other hand, when snorted and/or smoked in the form of crack, it is very dangerous and will cause severe problems. The same argument should be applied to the use of marijuana medically.

Marijuana is an excellent nausea suppressant and appetite enhancer. It is very useful in treating the symptoms of cancer, HIV and hepatitis C, as well as glaucoma and other diseases. There is no argument that it has no recreational use; however, clearly it does have medical benefits.

In short, the problem is not with the medication, but the medication user. My position thus is I am very much in support of medical marijuana and adamantly opposed to recreation marijuana—and all other drugs.


Con

earl-henslinEarl R. Henslin, Psy.D., B.C.E.T.S., is a marriage, family and child counselor with the Christian counseling group Henslin and Associates in Brea, Calif.; an instructor at Rosemead Graduate School of Psychology; and author of This Is Your Brain on Joy: How the New Science of Happiness Can Help You Feel Good and Be Happy:.

Con Argument: Medical Marijuana Should Be Illegal.

In 1996, California voters approved the use of medical marijuana for those suffering from chronic pain, nausea, or conditions from which patients cannot get relief from other drugs. It was marketed to the voters for helping patients with terminal cancer.

Get in on the Debate!

Sound off! Share your opinions about medical marijuana in the comments section below.

  1. The FDA announced in 2006 there were “No sound scientific studies” that supported the use of medical marijuana. Why is there any debate? Any physician who prescribed a drug unapproved by the FDA would lose his or her license. Why is this one drug above the law? The state of California is knowingly violating federal law by allowing the use of “medical marijuana.”
  2. Long-term marijuana use leads to structural changes in the brain. One study showed hippocampal volume in cannabis users was inversely correlated with cumulative exposure to the drug in the left, but not right, hemisphere—a finding that suggests “the left hippocampus may be particularly vulnerable to the effects of cannabis exposure and may be more closely related to the emergence of psychotic symptoms.”
  3. Atrial fibrillation should be included in the cardiovascular complications of marijuana smoking. Physicians should be aware of this particular association and carefully investigate patients with marijuana-related palpitations, dizziness or fainting. On the other hand, whenever a young patient without predisposing factors develops atrial fibrillation, the possibility of marijuana smoking should be examined as a potential cause. Although the exact clinical impact of this association is not clear, yet its incidence in the general population is probably underestimated.

This is a simple, cursory review. Is there any doubt about the need for FDA trials before a drug is used in society? Why does marijuana escape standard drug trials? Do we want scientific trials, or do we move drugs to the marketplace by popular vote?

Rebuttals
rebuttals
Dr. Henslin’s

Dr. Wallick makes an interesting comparison between marijuana and cocaine. The cocaine that is used as topical anesthetic is for a one-time purpose under the observation and care of physician. The quality of this topical anesthetic is known, and is compounded by a pharmacy. According to the National Institute of Drug Abuse, research on medical marijuana is hampered by the inconsistency and variability of the THC samples. The adverse effects of smoked marijuana on the respiratory system are outweighing the potential benefits. In fact, marijuana smoke contains 50 to 70 percent more carcinogenic hydrocarbons than tobacco smoke.
Dr. Wallick’s

True, marijuana is not a cure for any illness. But there is no question that it alleviates symptoms and makes patients more comfortable. It is also true that the drug has side effects. So do most medications. Listen to the TV ads which warn of possible death. I think we should treat marijuana like other medication. Take aspirin for example, which can cause side effects like internal bleeding. By the way, it is doubtful that aspirin would receive FDA approval today. Think about that the next time you have a headache. Marijuana as medicine works. Let’s make it available to those who need it.

Home remedies + science = do-it-yourself survival medicine! Get prepared for disasters with TheSurvivalDoctor’s e-books.

You May Also Like

Original article appeared in March/April 2009 issue of My Family Doctormagazine.

  • Tara Smith

    I am a student from Melba High School, in Melba, Idaho. For government we are supposed to ask an expert or someone that knows quite a bit about a government related topic and write a paper on it. I was wondering if you had time to answer a few questions that I have below? It would mean a lot!
    1. What are your opinions on the legalization of marijuana?
    2. How has the legalization of marijuana increased/decreased our economy?
    3. Where do you think the United States will stand within the next 10-20 years? Do you think marijuana will be legalized federally?

  • Pingback: Weed Vs. Liquor Research | maneb215

  • Pingback: Medical Marijuana: Pros & Cons of Budding Legalization - The UMHS Pulse

  • hecate

    marijuana is not actually physically addictive, its only psychologically. and only 9% of users get addicted compared to the 25% that get addicted to prescripted painkillers.

    marijuana is nicknamed the ‘gateway drug’ meaning once you smoke pot, you’re more likely to get hooked on more dangerous substances, such as cocaine or meth. THIS ISNT TRUE new studies have shown :) marijuana is also nicknamed the ‘terminus drug’ because most users stop at marijuana. granted, some do move onto different drugs, but thats just stereotypical. marijuana can kill cancerous cells, treat glaucoma, ease nausea, stimulate hunger in chemo and AIDS patients. why cant these sick people these sick, dying people deserve to alleviate their pain, and who is one to tell them that they cannot??

  • Pingback: Legalizing Medical Marijuana on the Navajo Nation, could it become a reality - www.arizonamedicalmarijuanacard.info | www.arizonamedicalmarijuanacard.info

  • jaycik

    i am writing a report on medical marijuana pros in cons anyone got any tips

    • repealit1975

      yeah, do through research and don’t listen to the completely false statements in this article about how cannabis will ruin your life etc. from a 22 year ‘stoner’ who has led a very succesful life. :)

      • Ladehawk

        lol @22 yr. of age, that’s hardly old enough to qualify as being a successful life. I’m 59 and can actually make that claim for having a successful life having “indulged” for 44 years. And without it being a gateway drug into stronger drugs. It’s actually quite beneficial for a number of medical maladies. Speaking strictly from an experienced standpoint.

        • repealit1975

          here here! I’m 36 so admittedly things could still go wrong lol

        • jimmypots

          uhm he meant 22 years of use

  • Sadie james

    please help

    • http://thesurvivaldoctor.com/ James Hubbard, MD, MPH

      Sorry, Sadie, You’re going to have to look it up. I have nothing else to add.

  • Sadie james

    Tying to write an argumentative essay on marijuana would like more information on this subject.

  • Eddie

    I have used marijuana as I pleased(every day) since 14 years old, I excelled in school and decided to join the Air force to train as an aircraft mechanical engineer. I stopped using a week before heading off to boot camp for a tough 3 months training. My motivation was recognised and was made course leader. By the end at graduation I recieved the award for ourstanding personal qualities over the other 60 candidates(a third who failed to complete) for my drive,intuition and adaptability. After recruits I went to the technical college and passed every subject with over 80% and at the end recieved a high distinction overall. I finished this trade aquiring the diploma and a promotion ahead of my peers. I made the desicion that I would rather help mother nature as she has helped me so now I am on the path towards my masters in ecology. I don’t smoke marijuana but use it in cooking where it’s possible. Legalize it!

    • Ladehawk

      Excellent argument! Bravo.

  • Ronnie

    Very lovely yet misused plant..

    there are safer and more effective medz out there. The memory loss from long-term use is awful. People forgetting what they are going to say as they say it.. so tragic.. alcohol and smokes kill.. lets open the gate and destroy minds..

    • hecate

      Actually, studies have shown that “any effects on [ones] memory will wear off after a few hours” (Moyer 1). and marijuana is safer than almost all the prescriptions out there. there are NO known cases of overdosing on marijuana.
      so yes. get your facts straight before posting some bull.

    • repealit1975

      wrong wrong wrong, I’ve been smoking 22 years and have never suffered from these things, neither have my friends who also do the same. get your facts straight.

      • repealit1975

        how can something be ‘safer’ than a substance (cannabis) that has no LD50 rating? it’s safer than water in those terms.